Last Updated on October 8, 2025 by Writer
The cool mornings we’ve been waiting for have finally arrived on Anna Maria Island — and the fishing is heating up fast. October cold fronts are rolling through, and every drop in water temperature kicks the fish into feed mode. From snook and redfish in the backwaters to mackerel and kingfish off the beaches, it’s a great time to be on the water.
Snook & Redfish in the Shallows
Snook fishing has been excellent around mangrove edges, bridges, and sandy potholes on the flats. These fish are aggressively feeding ahead of the cooler months. Live bait — especially pilchards and pinfish — continues to produce, but artificial lures like paddle tails and topwater plugs have been hot early in the morning.
Redfish are showing up in good numbers across the flats and around oyster bars. We’re seeing plenty of slot-sized fish mixed in with some overslot bruisers. On high tides, target mangrove edges; as the tide drops, move out to the sand holes and points.
Mackerel, Kings & Nearshore Bite
The nearshore bite has been just as strong. Spanish mackerel are schooling up just off the beaches, feeding on glass minnows and small threadfins. Keep an eye out for diving birds — that’s where the action is. Throw silver spoons, Gotcha plugs, or free-line live bait for nonstop fun.
We’re also starting to see more kingfish showing up in the 5–10 mile range, which will only improve as water temps continue to dip through October and November.
Perfect Fall Conditions
It’s one of the best times of year to fish Anna Maria Island — comfortable weather, lighter crowds, and fish that are feeding hard before winter. Whether you’re after a backwater slam or a nearshore mix, this fall pattern delivers steady action day after day.
If you’re ready to get in on the bite, now’s the time to book your Anna Maria Island fishing charter with Capt. Nate’s Fishing Charters. Experience world-class inshore and nearshore fishing with a local guide who knows these waters inside and out.
