Last Updated on March 28, 2023 by Eric Bonneman

Nestled along the beautiful Gulf Coast of Florida, Anna Maria Island (AMI) is a hidden gem for fishing enthusiasts. This slice of paradise, stretching from Bradenton to Holmes Beach, offers a diverse range of inshore fish species and some of the best fishing experiences you can find. Captain Nate is your ticket to unlocking the incredible angling opportunities that the waters around AMI have to offer.

The Best Fish to Target in AMI

From novice anglers to seasoned veterans, everyone can find a thrilling adventure in the rich waters surrounding Anna Maria Island. Let’s explore the top 10 inshore fish species you can target while fishing with Captain Nate off the coast of Bradenton and Holmes Beach.

a picture of AMI Fishing: 10 Species to Target off Bradenton & Holmes Beach with Captain Nate


Snook are highly sought-after game fish, famous for their strong fights and acrobatic leaps. The waters around Anna Maria Island, especially near mangroves and other structures, provide the perfect habitat for these hard-fighting fish. Catching a trophy snook is an unforgettable experience!


Redfish are known for their distinctive red color and the unique black spot on their tails. These strong fighters can be found in the grass flats and mangrove estuaries around Anna Maria Island. Redfish are popular among anglers for their delicious taste and challenging pursuit.

Spotted Seatrout

Spotted seatrout, or simply “trout,” are abundant around Anna Maria Island, making them a popular target for inshore fishing. These fish are known for their beautiful silver body covered in small black spots. Trout can be found in the grass flats, channels, and backwater areas around AMI.

a picture of AMI Fishing: 10 Species to Target off Bradenton & Holmes Beach with Captain Nate


Tarpon, also known as the “Silver King,” are a must-catch species for any serious angler. These giant fish can reach up to 200 pounds and are famous for their acrobatic jumps and powerful runs. Tarpon can be found in the waters off Anna Maria Island during their annual migration.

Black Drum

The black drum is a hard-fighting inshore species often found around structures like docks, bridges, and oyster bars. These bottom-dwellers are characterized by their dark coloration and the whisker-like barbels around their mouths. Black drum are known for their strong, steady pull when hooked.


Sheepshead are unique-looking fish with distinct black stripes and a mouth full of teeth. They are commonly found around structures like piers, jetties, and oyster bars, where they feed on crustaceans. Sheepshead are notorious for stealing bait, so a skilled touch is needed to catch these crafty fish.

a picture of AMI Fishing: 10 Species to Target off Bradenton & Holmes Beach with Captain Nate

Mangrove Snapper

Mangrove snapper are a popular inshore species found around docks, bridges, and mangroves. These fish are characterized by their red-brown color and sharp teeth. Mangrove snapper are known for their aggressive strikes and tasty, white meat, making them a favorite target for anglers around Anna Maria Island.


Flounder are flat, camouflaged fish that blend in with the sandy bottom. These ambush predators can be found near structures like docks and bridges or on the grass flats surrounding Anna Maria Island. Flounder are prized for their delicate, white meat and challenging pursuit.

Jack Crevalle

Jack crevalle are strong, fast-swimming fish known for their aggressive behavior and powerful fights. These fish can be found in schools near shorelines, mangroves, and other structures. Jack crevalle are a thrilling catch, offering exciting action on light tackle.

a picture of AMI Fishing: 10 Species to Target off Bradenton & Holmes Beach with Captain Nate

Spanish Mackerel

Spanish mackerel are a fast, schooling fish that can be found in the waters off Anna Maria Island. Known for their beautiful silver bodies and distinctive yellow spots, these fish are a favorite among anglers for their high-speed runs and acrobatic leaps when hooked. Spanish mackerel are not only fun to catch, but they also make for a delicious meal when grilled or smoked.

Fish With Us!

Anna Maria Island, with its diverse range of inshore fish species, offers an unparalleled fishing experience for anglers of all skill levels. Captain Nate can help you explore the fantastic opportunities that the waters off Bradenton and Holmes Beach have to offer. Whether you’re after the powerful fight of a snook or the tasty reward of a mangrove snapper, there’s no shortage of exciting inshore fishing action to be found around AMI. Book a trip with Captain Nate today and experience the thrill of Anna Maria Island fishing for yourself!